Chicago Physician Accused in Fatal Ohio Shooting of Former Spouse and Her Husband

Michael David McKee, 39, has been charged with premeditated aggravated murder in the deaths of Monique Tepe, 39, and Dr. Spencer Tepe, 37. The couple was discovered deceased inside their home on December 30, after concerns were raised when Spencer failed to appear for work at his dental practice.
McKee was taken into custody in Illinois over the weekend and appeared in Winnebago County Court on Monday. During the brief hearing, he waived his right to contest extradition, allowing authorities to begin the process of transferring him back to Ohio, where the case will be prosecuted.
Court Appearance and Extradition Timeline
Wearing jail-issued clothing and restraints, McKee entered the courtroom without visible reaction. The presiding judge scheduled a status hearing for January 19 to confirm his return to Franklin County, Ohio. Law enforcement agencies in both states are coordinating the transfer.
Once returned, McKee is expected to face formal proceedings related to the double homicide charges.
A Crime Marked by Silence and Unanswered Questions

The investigation initially puzzled authorities. Police reported that the Tepe residence showed:
No forced entry
No signs of robbery
No weapon recovered
No indication of a murder-suicide
Notably, the couple’s young children and family dog were unharmed, adding to the disturbing nature of the crime.
Security footage later released by police showed a figure walking near the home in the early morning hours. The video sparked public tips and expanded the search across state lines, ultimately leading investigators to McKee.
How Authorities Discovered the Tragedy
Concern began when Spencer Tepe did not arrive at his dental office a behavior colleagues described as highly uncharacteristic. After attempts to reach the family failed, police conducted a welfare check later that day.
Inside the home, officers found both victims with fatal gunshot wounds. While full autopsy reports are still pending, the Franklin County Coroner’s Office has confirmed the deaths are being treated as homicides.
Family Statement Emphasizes Justice and Healing
In a statement released after the arrest, family members described the development as a meaningful step forward.
 “We are committed to protecting the children they leave behind and honoring the love and kindness they shared.”
A Relationship From the Past Under Legal Scrutiny
Court documents show that McKee and Monique were married in 2015 and divorced in 2017. Investigators have not publicly discussed motive, and McKee is presumed innocent as the case proceeds through the justice system.
What Comes Next
As prosecutors prepare their case, investigators continue reviewing forensic evidence and digital records. For the families involved, the legal process represents both a search for accountability and a long road toward healing. The case serves as a reminder that some acts of violence ripple far beyond the moment they occur leaving behind grief, questions, and a community seeking answers.