Teen charged in blunt force death of Walker County man initially thought to be victim of hit-and-run

A 17-year-old has been charged with the brutal killing of a Walker County man, initially thought to be a victim of a hit-and-run accident.

Walker County sheriff’s deputies responded to a 911 call just before 5 a.m. on Monday, where a passerby reported a person down in the median of Highway 78 near Scott’s Texaco in the Argo community.

The victim, identified as 40-year-old Jonathan O’Neill Foster, was transported to UAB Hospital, where he later succumbed to his injuries.

Sheriff Nick Smith announced in a press conference on Thursday that initial evidence suggested Foster had been struck by a vehicle. This led to a collaboration with Alabama State Troopers, who began investigating the case as a potential hit-and-run.

“In the early stages, all evidence pointed to a tragic traffic accident. However, as the investigation progressed, new information raised concerns about possible foul play,” Sheriff Smith stated.

Walker County investigators worked closely with state troopers to follow up on leads. 

On Wednesday afternoon, Smith revealed that the autopsy results indicated Foster had not died from a vehicle strike.

“This crucial finding shifted our focus and led us to explore other avenues to determine what truly happened to Mr. Foster,” he said.

Following extensive investigation and multiple interviews, authorities secured a murder warrant against the teenager. Due to the suspect's age, no further information will be released.

The sheriff has not disclosed the motive behind the crime, expressing condolences to Foster's family. 

“I want to extend my deepest condolences to the family and loved ones of Mr. Foster,” Sheriff Smith said. “Losing a loved one in such a violent and sudden manner is unimaginable. We stand with them during this difficult time.”

He reassured the community that their safety remains a top priority. 

“Cases like this are rare, and we are committed to maintaining peace and security in Walker County,” Smith added. He acknowledged that many questions remain but emphasized the limitations imposed by the suspect’s juvenile status. The teen is currently held in the Walker County Jail.

“We appreciate your patience and understanding as we seek justice for Mr. Foster,” he stated, urging anyone with additional information to contact the sheriff’s office. The investigation is ongoing.